Search This Blog

Tuesday, April 1, 2014

The Scarcity of Nigerian Stamps

It feels like it has been months since my last post. I have been taking a break from posting in order to concentrate on sorting out my stamps and organizing them into some kind of order. I have been trying to sort the multiple copies that I have of most issues into different printings, papers, shades, perforation types, and so on. As part of my study, I have sought out and acquired the only literature that I can find on the subject, which has turned out to be a few journal articles, written by my fellow study circle members. In the process of reading these articles, I have come across data regarding the issue quantities of many of Nigeria's classic stamps that illustrates why this country has so much upward potential to philatelists looking to get into a collecting area that simultaneously offers breadth, depth and scarcity.

For example, most of the stamps issued prior to 1914 were printed in quantities of less than 50,000 for each stamp, with the 10/- purple brown Queen Victoria of Lagos being the rarest regular issue, with only 420 printed. Within this period, there are scores of higher value stamps above 1/-, that had issue quantities of 5,000 or less. Even more interestingly, the order quantities of the post offices during the period prior to 1914 were quite low, being often just few thousand stamps. So the total issue quantities were often spread over a very large number of small printings. This is a boon for the shade, paper and perforation enthusiast, who can embark on the challenge of obtaining all known printings. Because the quantity of each printing is small, obtaining a full set of all printing types is quite a challenge. It is all the more challenging because there is no comprehensive reference source that lists and describes all the printings and explains how to identify them.

Even stamps that seem to be comparatively common, such as the halfpenny green and one penny carmine Queen Victoria stamps of Lagos, whose total issue quantities were around 800,000 to 1,000,000 were spread out over a massive 35-42 printings each, between 1885-1903. As one begins to study these stamps, it becomes apparent that the vast majority of the stamps on the market date from after 1897, and very few examples seem to be printed before 1890. This means of course, that the original 1884-1885 printings are in actual fact, every bit as scarce and elusive as the earlier 1d stamps from the earlier Crown CA or Crown CC issues. However, the standard stamp catalogues do not make this clear.

You would think that a stamp that had a quantity of less than 5,000 stamps would be worth thousands of dollars, since it is difficult to imagine more than 10-20% of the original quantity surviving. Yet, many of these stamps can still be had for as little as $100, and in some cases, even less than that.

To put in perspective, how ridiculously inexpensive these stamps are, it is useful to get some perspective by looking at what more common stamps from popular countries such as Great Britain, Canada, USA sell for.





From the USA, a $5 stamp from the 1893 Columbian Exposition Issue, was issued in a quantity of 27,350 stamps and sells for anywhere from several hundred dollars to thousands of dollars for a single mint stamp. Then there is this stamp from Great Britain:



It is the beautiful 1929 PUC pound. 61,000 of these stamps were issued in 1929. An average mint or used example will likely set you back at least $500 and a superb example will cost upwards of $1,000.

Or how about this stamp from Australia?

Type O3

This is the 1932 5/- Sydney Harbour Bridge stamp. 72,800 of these were issued. A canceled-to-order example will cost around $250 and a superb mint NH example will set you back about $1,000.

And lastly, this well known stamp from Canada:



This is the $5 Diamond Jubilee stamp from 1897. 15,500 were printed and while a poor used copy can be had for as little as $200, superb NH mint examples are now selling for well over $10,000.

Now let us look at similar Nigerian stamps from the same period.



First up, we have the two highest values in the Queen Victoria set from Northern Nigeria, which was issued in 1900. The total issue quantity of the 2/6d and 10/- was about the same at around approximately 8,000 stamps each - less than half of the quantity issued of the $5 Jubilee above. Yet the 2/6d can be obtained for around $100-$125 in mint condition and the 10/- is about $300-$500, which is curious given that they are both equally scarce.



Then we have this 10/- stamp from Niger Coast Protectorate. Again the total print quantity was just 5,000 stamps, which was spread out over at least three printings and three different perforations. Again, this stamp can be purchased in mint condition for $100-$200 and $200-$300 in used condition.

Last, but not least, there is the 10/- purple brown Queen Victoria stamp of Lagos:



420 of these were issued and a mint example can be purchased for between $1,000 and $2,000.

As you can see, these issues are way scarcer than any of the more famous stamps that have been issued by the more popular Western nations. However, what is also very promising about Nigeria is that it has a population base that is comparable to the USA, and its ecomomy is growing very rapidly. In addition, the restoration of democracy and the fight against corruption, are paving the way for the emergence of a middle class. With this comes the growth of popularity in hobbies involving various collectibles. It is not at all difficult to imagine what will happen to the value of these stamps if Nigeria develops a base of collectors similar to the USA, Australia, Great Britain or Canada.

Canada's 12 Pence Black, one of the 'top 13 most valuable postage stamps in the world' by China.org.cn.

For example, one of Canada's rarest stamps the 12d black above sold in New York in 2011 for $488,900 US. In 1851 51,000 stamps were printed, but only 1,450 were sold, with the rest being destroyed in 1857. Approximately 100 are thought to exist, in various states of condition today. This represents a survival rate of just under 7%. So with an issue quantity of 420 stamps, the 10/- purple brown of Lagos could easily be just as rare as the above stamp, if just under 25% of the stamps survived.

This is just a few of the scarce stamps that this country has to offer. There are also scores of scarce varieties, specimen stamps, multiples and covers that are rarities by world standards. This is a country that I believe has nearly unlimited potential for the forward looking philatelist.

No comments:

Post a Comment